|
Drug
companies are now spending $259 million dollars every
year to sway parents to put their inattentive or hyperactive
children on amphetamines. The ad campaigns are apparently
working. The number of American children who are being
treated with drugs for Attention deficit and Hyperactive
Disorder (ADHD) more than tripled in the 1990s. A study
published this summer in the American Journal of Psychiatry
revealed that over 2 million American children were
being medicated for ADHD in 1997. The number is much
higher now. Drug companies earned $1.5 billion dollars
last year from the sale of ADHD drugs.
Thirty years
ago the condition we now call ADHD was diagnosed mostly
in fidgety young boys, who had difficulty staying in
their seats in class. By the end of the 1990s, ADHD
had spread from boys to girls and to all age groups.
During the decade from 1987 to 1997, the rate of treatment
for ADHD increased 378%. Significant increases in the
rates of treatment for ADHD were evident across nearly
all sociodemographic groups, with the largest increases
among children from poor, near-poor, and low-income
families and children ages 12 to 18. Among children
who received treatment for ADHD, there was a significant
decrease in the number of visits to the doctor, but
an increase in the number of prescriptions for stimulant
drugs.
Now
adolescents in high school, or young adults in college,
as well as toddlers are being diagnosed more frequently;
so are many parents of kids with ADHD. Most are being
given drugs: amphetamines or antidepressants. The numbers
are likely even higher today, judging from a recent
and still unpublished survey of elementary school teachers
by psychologist William Pelham of the State University
of New York in Buffalo. Mr. Pelham surveyed teachers
all around the country and found that approximately
7% of the elementary school children had been diagnosed
with ADHD.
Once
considered primarily a only childhood condition, ADHD
is now known to be a lifelong condition for as many
as half of those troubled with its hallmark symptoms
of inattention, distractibility, impulsivity and emotional
instability starting before age 7.
Despite its persistence in as much as 1 percent of the
population, the disorder often remains undiagnosed for
a decade or more, finally becoming debilitating when
academic, social or work pressures mount after high
school graduation.
That's
why ADHD seems to break out like an epidemic on college
campuses every fall. "The structure of high school
is such that students with ADHD can slip through unnoticed,"
says Robert J. Resnick, a professor of psychology at
Randolph-Macon College in Ashland, Va. He's also the
author of "The Hidden Disorder: The Clinician's
Guide to Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in
Adults."
"But
college is a different story," Resnick adds. "The
stepped-up demands of higher education, coupled with
the absence of many familiar external structures and
controls, bring these students problems with organization
and distractibility to the forefront. They just can't
fake academic performance any longer. When referred
to the college's support services for help, they find
out -- many of them for the first time -- that they
have had ADHD for many years."
Female
college students are just as likely as male students
to be affected, despite the disproportionate number
of boys diagnosed with ADHD in the early grades, says
Resnick, a former president of the American Psychological
Association.
"The
condition is no respecter of gender," Resnick explains.
"However, the symptoms in young males and females
are often different. Boys with ADHD tend to be more
active and aggressive, which results in earlier referral
for assessment by parents and teachers. In elementary
school, the ratio of boys diagnosed with ADHD to girls
diagnosed is three- or four-to-one. On the college campus,
the ratio is one-to-one."
Legal
Speed: Dangerous Prescription Drugs
The most commonly prescribed drugs for ADHD include
Adderal,
Dexadrine, Ritalin,
and Cylert. Adderal and Dexedrine
are both Amphetamines with high
potential for dependence. The Physicians
Drug Reference lists a strong WARNING for these two
drugs, stating:
"AMPHETAMINES
HAVE A HIGH POTENTIAL FOR ABUSE. ADMINISTRATION OF AMPHETAMINES
FOR PROLONGED PERIODS OF TIME MAY LEAD TO DRUG DEPENDENCE
AND MUST BE AVOIDED. PARTICULAR ATTENTION SHOULD BE
PAID TO THE POSSIBILITY OF SUBJECTS OBTAINING AMPHETAMINES
FOR NON THERAPEUTIC USE OR DISTRIBUTION TO OTHERS, AND
THE DRUGS SHOULD BE PRESCRIBED OR DISPENSED SPARINGLY."
Adderal
(amphetamine and dextroamphetamine) and Dexedrine
(dextroamphetamine)
"Amphetamines are non-catecholamine sympathomimetic
amines with CNS stimulant activity. Peripheral actions
include elevation of systolic and diastolic blood pressures
and weak bronchodilator and respiratory stimulant action."
"There
is neither specific evidence which clearly establishes
the mechanism whereby amphetamine produces mental and
behavioral effects in children, nor conclusive evidence
regarding how these effects relate to the condition
of the central nervous system."
Ritalin
(Methylphenidate hydrochloride)
Ritalin, is another central nervous system stimulant
known as Methylphenidate hydrochloride. "The mode
of action in man is not completely understood, but methylphenidate
presumably activates the brain stem arousal system and
cortex to produce its stimulant effect.
"There
is neither specific evidence which clearly establishes
the mechanism whereby methylphenidate produces its mental
and behavioral effects in children, nor conclusive evidence
regarding how these effects relate to the condition
of the central nervous system."
Cylert
(pemoline)
Cylert (pemoline) is a central nervous system stimulant,
but structurally dissimilar from the other ADHD drugs.
Although studies indicate that Cylert may act in animals
through altering Dopamine, the exact mechanism and site
of action of the drug in man is not known. There is
neither specific evidence which clearly establishes
the mechanism whereby CYLERT produces its mental and
behavioral effects in children, nor conclusive evidence
regarding how these effects relate to the condition
of the central nervous system.
Controversy
or Bias
Most psychiatrists, the MDs that do little or no counseling
and prescribe psychoactive drugs for a living, see the
large upsurge in the diagnosis and the prescription
of drug therapy for ADHD as hopeful. They point out
that ADHD is a serious condition that, left untreated,
will cause a significant impairment in the child’s
functioning in school, at home and with their peers.
They say that hundreds of studies show that ADHD drugs
work and have not been proven to have long-term adverse
effects. Some, such as psychiatrist Peter Jensen of
Columbia University, say the problem is that not enough
children are getting drugs to help them with the disorder
Medical sociologist
Peter Conrad of Brandeis University, on the other hand,
decries the increased use of ADHD drugs. He says it's
an example of how Americans have come to treat normal
differences among children and adults as evidence of
disease. Mr. Conrad says, “More and more of human
difficulties, I think, have been defined as medical
problems, and in some ways, we've turned a lot of human
difference into pathology.”
Other critics
blame drug companies for an overuse of drugs to treat
ADHD. A recent study sponsored by the National Institutes
of Mental Health (NIMH) gave its stamp of approval to
the use of ADHD drugs among children. The agency compared
ADHD medication to behavior modification training and
found that medication was more effective.
Psychologist
William Pelham participated in the NIMH study and disagreed
with that conclusion. He said, “A lot of studies
have shown that actually, if you start with the effective
treatments for ADHD that are non-pharmacological –
and those effective treatments are called behavior modification
– that's parent training, working with teachers
or working with the children directly. If you start
with those interventions first, as many as half of ADHD
children, or a little more than half, don't ever move
to needing medication.
Psychiatrist
Peter Jensen, who also participated in the NIMH study,
agrees that some children benefit from behavior modification
alone. However, he says children who get both do best.
But, he says, if you have to choose, the study shows
you'd be more likely to succeed with drugs.
Several separate
and powerful forces fueled the boom in ADHD diagnosis
and medication. Pelham points first to an event outside
the world of medicine, in the field of education. It
happened in 1991 and made the ADHD diagnosis extremely
popular. He says “The US Office of Education identified
ADHD as a handicapping condition that would make a child
eligible for special education under some conditions.
That change really caused all the school districts in
the country to have to look for ADHD children and determine
whether or not they needed special services. That caused
a really big increase in the number of kids identified.”
National
Public Radio’s reporter, Snigdha Prakash points
out that “Bigger classes and increased emphasis
on standardized achievement tests also may have added
to the numbers of those diagnosed with ADHD, as parents
looked to medicine to solve their children's learning
problems. The pharmaceutical industry worked to make
sure that those solutions came increasingly in the form
of ADHD drugs. In 2000 and 2001, drug makers introduced
long-acting versions of the two main ADHD drugs. The
new formulations had practical advantages. Children
could take a pill once a day before going to school
and didn't have to go to the school nurse for another
dose. Drug companies pushed that advantage hard, spending
$259 million last year marketing their ADHD drugs, up
from just $9 million five years ago. Most of the money
was spent on pitching the drugs to doctors.”
Psychiatrist
Michael Brody, the former head of child psychiatry at
St. Elizabeth's Hospital in Washington, says, “It
means a lot for the drug company if you start your patient
on these medications, because these medications go on
for years, and that's a lot of money to these drug companies.”
According
to the money manager for Sanford Bernstein & Company,
Americans bought $1.5 billion of ADHD drugs last year.
Managed-care insurance companies have also played a
significant role in the drug boom, because they limit
access to specialists, such as psychologists and Naturopathic
physicians. Most children get their ADHD diagnosis and
drugs from their pediatricians. Dr. Brody says pediatricians
are often too quick to diagnose ADHD and prescribe drugs
to children without evaluating the stresses in the home
or other emotional factors that could be treated by
non-drug methods, including counseling.
“Back
in the early '70s, the parents were very cautious and
fearful that their child might have some adverse drug
effect, but now a lot of the parents come in requesting
medication, “ according to Dr. Daniel Safer, of
Johns Hopkins Medical Center. And perhaps worse, ADHD
drugs have cleared the way for increasing use of other
drugs for other psychiatric disorders among children,
ranging from mood disorders to shyness, according to
sociologist Peter Conrad.
(Note:
Some of the quotes in this article come from a report
on National Public Radio, Morning Edition, September
25, 2003, 10:00-11:00 AM, by Snigdha Prakash, entitled,
Increasing diagnosis and drug treatment of children
with ADHD ignites controversy among professionals, Article
Text: BOB EDWARDS, host.)
Dr.
Hansen’s Recommendations
In place of Adderal, Dexedrine, Ritalin, and Cylert,
I recommend non-drug therapy that includes counseling
and nutritional supplements that help the body calm
the nervous system and make enough of the natural calming
neurohormones to deal with the stresses of modern living.
For my 6-12 year old patients with ADHD, I recommend
a product known as Acuity™.
For teenagers or adults, I recommend higher potency
products, including Tranquil
Clarity™
and GSE
Ultra 110™.
Additionally, for all age groups I recommend testing
for Neurohormones (Serotonin, Dopamine, Norepinephrine
and Epinephrine) and treating the deficiencies and excesses
with the appropriate nutritional building blocks for
these essential neurohormones, including 5HTP
and L-Tyrosine.
These
products do not cause any adverse interactions with
Adderal
or Ritalin, however, since
the amphetamines do not cure the problem and are associated
significant adverse effects, I recommend that patients
be weaned off of these drugs carefully over several
weeks taking the natural products to correct the underlying
neurotransmitter imbalances.
For
more information about Acuity™
and Testimonials from parents who have given Acuity
to their children, please
click here .
For more information about testing Neurohormones please
click here.
For more information about 5HTP , please
click here.
For
more information about L-Tyrosine , please
click here.
|